Changes

Jump to: navigation, search

Talk:Transmute Magic (5e Spell)

1,816 bytes added, 17:54, 23 April 2019
m
TK is Here!
:::::10) Could remove the Wisdom save altogether. But it would increase the power considerably. Currently it affects the spell's origin (in other words spellcaster), thus each spellcaster that casts spells in area gets a save. Will clarify wording to this.
:::::11) It would be overpowered to never give them a reroll.--Franken Kesey 10:21, 23 April 2019 (MDT)
 
:::::: '''6)''' I really do not understand what your fixation on Abjuration and "magic protection spells" are in relation to what you're saying in the spell; so it ''is counterable''? What does Private Sanctum have to do with this at all? Can you at least tell me just what you're trying to do here?
:::::: '''10)''' No-where in the spell does it say that effects the spell's origin, it just says that it effects anyone inside the area and then it goes on to list what it does spells in the area. Either you have it effect any spells that are cast into the area, or you have the spell effect any creature in the area, and it applies properties to their spells as they're cast no matter where they're casting. Otherwise, this is just a mess.
:::::: '''11)''' As it is, it's not overpowered to never give them a re-roll because ''it doesn't effect spellcasters''. Spells that allow people to resist their effects don't do it like the strange way that you've said it. We can look at other spells and see how it's done; firstly, when you enter the spell for the time on a turn, you must make the saving throw. Then, we can take some hostile effect spells (like [[SRD5:Hold_Person|Hold Person]]) and say that we definitely want someone to be under the effects for one turn, so they get to make their next saving throw at the end of their turn. Also, on a final note, you can simply say "When a creature enters the spell's area for the first time on a turn" instead of "first round these effects take affect, on every entry" - this is because when the spell comes into effect, creatures within its area enter its area.
:::::: I just really want to understand point '''6)''' though. That seems to be the main sticking point here. --[[User:TK-Squared|TK-Squared]] ([[User talk:TK-Squared|talk]]) 11:54, 23 April 2019 (MDT)

Navigation menu