Difference between revisions of "Talk:Crool (3.5e Race)"

From Dungeons and Dragons Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Text replace - "== Favor ==" to "== Ratings ==")
(updated rating)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
== Ratings ==
 
== Ratings ==
  
{{RC Favor
+
{{Rating
 
|rater=Ganteka Future
 
|rater=Ganteka Future
|points=1
+
|rating=dislike
|reason=Good work. Solid and straightforward. Has enough flavor and information to implement into a campaign. Racial traits are, again, straightforward, nothing fancy, but, it gets the job done and it knows what it is designed to be (and that fits with the flavor), a big brute. I naturally worry about LA races designed for melee, but, that's just a worry, being a fault of the system, and not of the race. So yeah, again, good work
+
|reason=<s>Good work. Solid and straightforward. Has enough flavor and information to implement into a campaign. Racial traits are, again, straightforward, nothing fancy, but, it gets the job done and it knows what it is designed to be (and that fits with the flavor), a big brute. I naturally worry about LA races designed for melee, but, that's just a worry, being a fault of the system, and not of the race. So yeah, again, good work.</s>
 +
The flavor is straightforward though not particularly entertaining, flowing well enough for understandability. The racial traits are however ''too straightforward'', offering nothing of interest to a player other than ability score adjustments. With LA tacked onto that, it makes me dislike it.
 
}}
 
}}

Revision as of 21:00, 21 July 2012

Ratings

RatedDislike.png Ganteka Future dislikes this article and rated it 1 of 4.
Good work. Solid and straightforward. Has enough flavor and information to implement into a campaign. Racial traits are, again, straightforward, nothing fancy, but, it gets the job done and it knows what it is designed to be (and that fits with the flavor), a big brute. I naturally worry about LA races designed for melee, but, that's just a worry, being a fault of the system, and not of the race. So yeah, again, good work.

The flavor is straightforward though not particularly entertaining, flowing well enough for understandability. The racial traits are however too straightforward, offering nothing of interest to a player other than ability score adjustments. With LA tacked onto that, it makes me dislike it.

Facts about "Crool (3.5e Race)"
DislikedGanteka Future +